What did the Trade Deadline mean for the Tribe?

The Indians needed a starter, they needed a right handed bat and they also needed a bullpen arm that could keep them in games when they don’t have a lead.

Lars Anderson is none of those things. Brent Lillibridge isn’t either. But maybe some of these guys at Triple A are???

I will accept the argument that they didn’t have the prospects needed to get Hunter Pence or Shane Victorino. They also didn’t have what was needed to get Zach Greinke . But, I won’t accept the argument that they did not have the players to make any deals. 1B and OF Gaby Sanchez was traded to the Pirates for Gorkys Hernandez, basically the 6^th best outfielder in their Farm System and a pitcher who doesn’t show up anywhere in their Top 20 prospects. Sanchez could have been had for Thomas Neal (acquired for Orlando Cabrera last season) and the same guy they traded for Lars Anderson. And the Indians would have lost what? Nothing.

I will accept the argument that one player can’t turn a team around. But I won’t accept that the right role players can help make a playoff push.  The AL Central will come down to whether or not Kevin Youkilis, Francisco Liriano and Brett Myers are better than Anibal Sanchez  and Omar Infante. In 45 service years those 5 players have combined for 5 All-Star appearances, yet those 5 players were good enough for the other two teams competing.

I will accept the argument that Chris Antonetti is handcuffed by a cheap owner. But I won’t accept that the Indians couldn’t have improved this team without adding money to the payroll.  Once again we visit Gaby Sanchez. He is up for arbitration this season but his .200 BA isn’t going to help him much there, he’s making about 500K for 2012. 

Was Gaby Sanchez going to make the Indians a playoff team, who knows. But Gaby Sanchez is a right handed bat with 20 homer pop. Instead the Indians picked up another left handed 1B that will do nothing other than block Matt LaPorta from ever getting called up.

This really shouldn’t have come as a surprise to anyone. When the team traded for Lillibridge we should have realized the move was strictly made to keep the wear and tear off of Kipnis, Brantley and Cabrera, which is the 2013 core. The moves the Indians made, allowed them to be sellers in the quietest way possible. The door is open for a lot of waiver deals. Kotchman, Damon, Lopez, Lowe and anyone in the bullpen who’s last name doesn’t start with a P.

The Tribe front office took the easy way out, rather than calling themselves sellers and alienating an already alienated fan base or risking prospects they just did nothing of consequence. Much easier to explain in two weeks when they are 8 games out and fighting for 3^rd.

The Other 58 (aka I'm so glad it's over)

As promised the final 58 match-ups. This is pretty much entirely guess work, keep RPIs close, keep travel distance close and look for interesting scenarios that you can find without tons of research.

Nobody can really explain how it’s done by the big boys. One day we can find out. Some teams may not want to travel, others may be debating on whether to come back the following year or wait a year. Like Old Dominion did this year against Cleveland State.

After numerous hours of my BracketBuster Map, Google Maps, RealTime RPI and many other things. I’ve finalized the last 58 match-ups with an average of 32 RPI points between the teams (25 points for the TV games, so not bad) and an average 577.9 miles per match-up, excluding Hawaii.

In order to make it easiest for the folks to follow I’ll do it by Conference in Alphabetical Order with only the HOME TEAMS. So if you aren’t sure where to find the team you are looking for use “Find” in your browser.

America East
Home of the perennial 16 seed, the only team in D1 Basketball without a win and one of only two conferences not to get on TV. Its likely the winner of this conference will have to win in Dayton (if you know what I mean)

Fairfield @ Albany
Both teams could use this as a kickstart to jump to the top of their leagues
Presbyterian @ Maine
Teams are one apart in RPI, despite a decent chunk of mileage
Hampton @ New Hampshire
Two more teams that are one apart in RPI
James Madison @ Vermont
Vermont went to the NIT last year and is one game behind conference leaders Stony Brook. JMU has struggled in the CAA so far.

Big Sky
Weber St. has come out of nowhere and Montana is right there as well. The winner is probably looking at a 15 seed, but with the right match-up could slide up to 14.

Portland St @ Montana
Relative proximity
UC Davis @ Northern Arizona
My apologies to Northern Arizona, but good news is you get a win.
Texas A&M CC @ Northern Colorado
Remember when they made the tournament and everyone was calling them TamiFlu?
San Jose St @ Sacramento State
Proximity
Nevada @ Weber State (see yesterday’s TV match-ups)

Big South
Is the top of the Big South for real? This is the only chance to find out. Teams will need a good showing to help boost the tourney winners chance of avoiding a play-in (ahem Opening Round) game.

Siena @ Charleston Southern
Charleston Southern will have a say in the Big South title when things are said and done. Siena has been to the tourney before but aren’t in the race this season.
UNC Wilmington @ Coastal Carolina
If Coastal Carolina were an away rteam this year they would have been on TV. Probably the #2 or #3 snub for home teams.
IUPUI @ Gardner-Webb
Another average match-up simply due to travel and league restrictions I tried to set.
UMBC @ Radford
I would have loved to send UMBC to Towson for the battle of 2nd worst team in Maryland (Yes, the Wizards are that bad). But both were away teams.
Delaware St @ VMI
The last game I picked, so it’s not a great match-up. But surprised that the travel worked out.

Big West
Let’s just put this out there the Big West is a nightmare to project especially with most of the teams being between 220-340 in RPI. They have to travel somewhere but it has to be reasonable.

Not going to discuss each one, because they are mostly just regional.

Southern Utah @ CS-Fullerton
Idaho St @ CS-Northridge
Hawaii @ UC-Irvine
UTSA @ UC-Riverside
Probably the best game of the bunch, despite the travel. The RoadRunners have a great young coach and are right there in the Southland.
Texas St @ Pacific

Colonial Athletic Conference
Very few mid-major conferences have sent two DIFFERENT teams to the Final Four. In fact this is the only one to do it in at least 20 years. But this year the Strength of Schedule at the top of the league has the winner looking at a 14 or 15. GMU and VCU will be on TV, but need their league mates to pick up some good wins as well.

Rider @ Delaware
81 miles apart, 6 spots apart in RPI. Could you ask for an easier one?
UNC Asheville @ George Mason (TV Match-up)
Campbell @ Georgia State
Similar RPIs, not to far apart. Becomes the theme when you are predicting 71 games.
Niagara @ Hofstra
I don’t understand Hofstra they are 7-16. Yet may have single handedly destroyed two teams chances at at-large bids (wins against Iona and Cleveland State)
Youngstown St @ Northeastern
Two teams in good conferences that are looking to break out from the middle of the pack.
Buffalo @ VCU (TV Match-up)

Horizon League
Very few mid-major conferences have sent the SAME team to the Final Four in back to back years. In fact this is the only one to do it EVER. But that team is in a down year and a lack of recognition outside said team hurts this league in the National Spotlight. There are some very good teams though in this conference.

Indiana State @ Butler
I’ve heard rumors this game has already been leaked. It’s a no-brainer. Two tourney teams from last year, in true mid-major conferences, 80 miles apart and very close in RPI.
UNI @ Cleveland State (TV Match-up)
Marist @ Detroit
The ever-underachieving Detroit team really should be able to win this game. As you will read below I wanted to send BGSU there, but that didn’t work.
Western Illinois @ Green Bay
Two teams that are similar in RPI, similar in record and have moderate travel.
Oakland @ Milwaukee
Oakland has probably underperformed this season, but Milwaukee might bring out the best in them. If I had to put any game of this group on TV, I’d pick this one (over Kent State/College of Charleston)

Metro Atlantic Athletic Conference
The MAAC is in the midst of a logjam up top. Three teams sit there tied for first at 9-2, and all have 16 or 17 wins. The question must be asked if Manhattan and Loyola MD are for real. People seem to think Iona. This is exactly what BracketBusters is all about.

Hartford @ Canisius
Close in RPI and a bus ride distance for these two teams that have combined for 8 wins on the year.
Akron @ Iona (TV Match-up)
Old Dominion @ Loyola Maryland (TV Match-up)
Stony Brook @ Manhattan
58 miles apart, in terms of proximity there are only two or three other combinations of conference leaders in different leagues that are closer than these two (Can you name them?)
Towson @ Saint Peter’s
Towson’s losing streak made the Cavaliers sorrows last season look reasonable. This is a game they can win and get to TWO on the season

Mid American Conference
Yes I am biased about this conference, it’s not as good as the Horizon. It hasn’t been for a few years, yet it still gets better coverage and more attention. However with three teams who could all surprise people come March it’s still tough at the top.

Tennesee State @ Ball State
Similar teams, fair amount of travel. Just kind of fit.
Boston University @ Bowling Green
I had Bowling Green going to Detroit for a picture perfect RPI match-up. And then realized Bowling Green was a home team. So instead they’ll host Boston U – the team directly ahead of them in RPI
Loyola-Chicago @ Central Michigan
One of 3 MAC/HL games in my predictions, I couldn’t pull the trigger on sending Wright State to Miami.
College of Charleston @ Kent State
These are the teams most likely snubbed for not getting a TV game. So they should play each other. Charleston is familiar with the area as they visited Cleveland last year for the NIT
Tennesee-Martin @ Miami (OH)
Proximity over anything else here just over 250 miles apart.
Valparaiso @ Ohio (TV Match-up)

MEAC
Only three teams from the Mid Eastern Athletic Conference participated this year, which is a shame because the only good one (Norfolk St 16-6) didn’t.

William & Mary @ Morgan State
Regional match-up for teams that are barely even relevant to alumni and students (Right Jed?)

Missouri Valley Conference
Ask anyone and they will tell you how good the Valley is. And then when they get two teams in the tournament the excuse is they beat each other up. I might buy that this year. 7 teams are within a game of 3rd place. But none of them are within four of 1st.

Toledo @ Bradley
Geno Ford left the MAC to head to Bradley where he hasn't exactly seen greener pastures yet.
St. Mary’s @ Creighton (TV Match-up)
Tennessee Tech @ Evansville
Will be a better match-up then the blind eye thinks. Tennesse Tech is the most likely team to beat Murray St in the OVC.
Morehead St @ Illinois State
Another OVC/MVC pairing.
Lamar @ Missouri State
These two could have been TV teams as well. Both still have a shot at the Tourney, Lamar more so then their host.

Ohio Valley Conference
The league of undefeated Murray State. The Racers have grabbed some attention for the OVC, which is an otherwise mediocre conference. They do have some tourney history though Morehead St the most recent upset special.

Eastern Michigan @ Austin Peay
EMU will have to Go Peay before the trip down south
Northern Illinois @ Eastern Illinois
Northern and Eastern aren’t as close as you would think but still a do-able bus trip
Wright State @ Eastern Kentucky
Teams are ten spots apart in RPI and 158 miles away from each other.
Central Arkansas @ Jacksonville State
Another location game, finding placing for all those teams in Tennessee and Kentucky that can’t play each other is tough.
Wichita St @ Murray State (TV Match-up)
Illinois-Chicago @ SIU Edwardsville
Illinois is way bigger than I thought. These schools significantly closer in RPI then they are in distance.

Southern
Another half participation league, difference is that arguably the three best teams out of this conference are in.

Liberty @ Appalachian State
Meh? It was getting late last night and I needed some good regional stuff.
Drexel @ Davidson (TV Match-up)

Southland
What can you say about the Southland other than that the winner of this conference gets the right to play in Ohio’s version of... JERSEY!

Disclaimer: The match-ups here were essentially how can I get these teams games without making someone travel 1200 miles.

Wofford @ McNeese State
See disclaimer
High Point @ Nicholls State
See disclaimer
IPFW @ Northwestern State
See disclaimer
Montana St @ Sam Houston University
1739 miles away, but can you really complain if you play your home games in Montana?
Binghamton @ Southeastern Louisiana
Let’s put it bluntly Binghamton is really really bad. They had to go somewhere that nobody could consider halfway decent and sending them to UC Davis wasn’t going to work.
Winthrop @ Stephen F. Austin
Remember that disclaimer?

Summit League
I actually like the Summit League it’s not a bunch of pretentious college basketball wannabes like the other league it shares man borders with (cough cough Missouri cough cough Valley), but every year they produce a good team or two. This year it’s Oral Roberts and South Dakota St. both who will feature on TV.

Fresno St @ Univ. of Missouri-KC
The worst routing match-up available. Fresno St isn’t a bad team, they aren’t a good team either. Unfortunately for them everyone near them is one of those two.
Western Michigan @ No Dakota St Univ.
If you are going to make someone go to Fargo, make it be someone from Kalamazoo.
Drake @ So Dakota St Univ. (TV Match-up)
The closest South Dakota State will ever get to a rap show in their gym… I should have made that joke yesterday sorry.
Southern Illiois @ Univ. of South Dakota
Another one where I was just trying to fit teams in
Long Beach State @ Oral Roberts University (TV Match-up)

WAC
The Western Athletic Conference has seen better days than it's basketball programs see right now.

Eastern Washington @ Idaho
It’ll do, not perfect though
SE Missouri St @ Louisiana Tech
I have to assume the only reason La Tech is in the WAC is because the Southland doesn’t have FBS football. What you want my comments to be basketball related?
UT-Arlington @ New Mexico St (TV Match-up)
Cal Poly @ Utah State
Once again regional match-up with attempt to not crush someone’s Strength of Schedule

WCC
Only Catholic schools with Mary in their name were allowed to participate this year for the West Coast Conference.

UCSB @ Loyola Marymount
Nobody likes a third wheel, but a fourth wheel is nice unless you are riding a tricycle. With all the hoopla of St. Mary’s, Gonzaga and BYU in the WCC, Loyola is that fourth wheel. Not as good as the top 3, but WAAAYYYYY better than the bottom 5.

ESPN BracketBuster: The Introduction

142 teams will participate in this year’s BracketBuster, in something that has never been done before. I will predict all 71 games. I know what you are thinking, no way anyone would have enough time to do that. Well guess what, someone does.

First off are the 13 TV games, unlike last year there seems to be no skeleton schedule. The network can put games at whatever time they want during the weekend. With 26 teams playing on TV, some standard must be set. I say you need to have 13 wins if you think you belong on TV. Why? These are teams that are looking for an a resume builder for the NCAA tournament. Most teams will play 5-6 games before the BracketBuster weekend. Last season 6 non-BCS conference teams were at-large bids. They had 30, 26, 25, 24, 23 and 22 wins. In 2010 8 non-BCS conference teams were at-large bids 29, 29, 27 26, 26, 26, 25 and 24 wins for those teams. Simple fact if you don’t have 13 yet the chances that you could get to 25 with 12-15 games left before Selection Sunday are slim. (This knocks out Butler, College of Charleston, Oakland and UCSB... it should have knocked out Buffalo, but they get a wild card on Rule #2)

With the exception of teams in probable “multi-bid” leagues West Coast Conference (WCC) and Missouri Valley (MVC) this season, you need to be within striking distance of winning the regular season. Two games out in a one bid league is still a lot of ground to make up, especially if you have lost to all three teams ahead of you (that is Kent State... however Buffalo is 1 game out and beat the team in first)

The third thing I look at is geographical logistics, a little more allowance is accepted for the TV games, as they want the 13 best matchup. But Hawaii to Maine is never going to happen unless they are the #1 and #2 teams in the country. I try to keep match-ups 4-13 within 700 miles. With the non TV match-ups try to keep it to 400 miles (Toledo was 3-24 when they visited a 14-15 CSU team in 2009).

After ranking all the teams my top 13 home teams in order are Creighton, Murray St Cleveland St, Oral Roberts, Iona, Davidson, South Dakota St., Ohio, Weber St, Virginia Commonwealth, George Mason, New Mexico St and Loyola Maryland (Kent St, Coastal Carolina, Missouri St and Wisconsin Milwaukee would be the next 4 in.)

For the away teams we go St. Mary’s, Wichita St, Nevada, Long Beach St, UNI, Drexel, Akron, Valparaiso, UNC-Asheville, Drake, Texas-Arlington, Buffalo, Old Dominion (The away teams this year are significantly weaker at the top then the home so Lamar, and College of Charleston are really the only two who get left out).

For the match-ups visit ... ESPN BracketBuster TV Matchups

ESPN BracketBuster The TV Match-Ups

For a little information on how I did this check out ESPN BracketBuster Introduction

You've seen the methods, you've seen the rankings assuming you read that above link (which of course you did, right)?

Here are the rankings one more time

HOME

Creighton, Murray St Cleveland St, Oral Roberts, Iona, Davidson, South Dakota St., Ohio, Weber St, Virginia Commonwealth, George Mason, New Mexico St and Loyola Maryland (Kent St, Coastal Carolina, Missouri St and Wisconsin Milwaukee would be the next 4 in).

AWAY

St. Mary’s, Wichita St, Nevada, Long Beach St, UNI, Drexel, Akron, Valparaiso, UNC-Asheville, Drake, Texas-Arlington, Buffalo, Old Dominion (The away teams this year are significantly weaker at the top then the home teams so Lamar, and College of Charleston are really the only two who get left out).

#20 St. Mary’s 21-2 (10-0, 1^st in West Coast Conference) @ #14 Creighton 20-2 (10-1, 1^st in Missouri Valley Conference)

Why Creighton over Murray St? Two reasons I’m not completely sold on Murray St, yes they are undefeated, yes they have 21 wins, but the Strength of Schedule is not there and Creighton’s overall resume is going to look better to the committee. The second reason being Wichita St and Creighton are in the same conference, they can’t play eachother. The Gaels and Bluejays have high RPIs and both boast double digit wining streaks. This will likely be the primetime game on Saturday night.

Wichita St 18-4 (9-2, 2^nd in WCC) @ #9 Murray St 21-0 (9-0, 1^st in Ohio Valley Conference)

As said before Creighton and Murray St are 1A and 1B for me. So it only makes sense to give the Racers the second best team available. This is the best chance for Murray St to prove me wrong and for the Shockers it is just another away game that will go very well in their bid for an at-large if they can’t win Arch Madness.

Long Beach St 16-6 (9-0, 1st in Big West) @ Oral Roberts 20-4 (12-0, 1st in Summit)

My #4 home vs my #4 away team – undefeated in their conferences, RPIs in the mid 40s and 36 wins between the two teams. Oral Roberts is looking to get back to the tournament for the first time since 2008 the third of three straight trips. Led by Casper Ware, the 49ers were a win away from going back to the Big Dance, after a 3 year self-imposed probation that spanned 2008-2010.

Northern Iowa 14-9 (4-7, 7th in MVC) @ Cleveland State 18-4 (8-2, 1st in Horizon League)

While these two teams don’t have a history against eachother, both bring a level of recognition as they have made their names in the NCAA tourney. CSU with their win against Wake Forest in 2009 and UNI over Kansas is 2010. The Panthers are the only team to make a TV game not ranked in the Top 4 of their conference, however they have the benefit of having played 17 of their 21 games against teams in the RPI, so they have a nice little number next to their name there. Often times the selections have to do with regional travel. While Nevada might be a better match-up the 1600 extra miles aren’t. So with a very small slate of teams worthy from the away side, this match-up makes more sense and would help both teams out.

Akron 14-7 (6-1, 1st in Mid-American Conference) @ Iona 16-5 (8-2, T2nd in Metro Atlantic Athletic Conference

I don’t really know what Iona is, ranked high in RPI, ranked high in the mid-major poll and they are the perfect example of how not having any games against really bad teams is better than beating average teams. After the starting the year 2-5 Akron has shot up 100 spots in the RPI over the past month by winning 12 of their last 14 games. They lead the MAC East (and would be the overall 1 seed in the MAC Tourney at this point).

Nevada 18-3 (7-0, 1st in Western Athletic Conference) @ Weber St 16-4 (8-1, 1st in Big Sky)

The Big Sky is not a well known conference, the WAC is a little bit better known but neither one if all that great. In what looks like a regional match-up, the Wolfpack and the Wildcats are both close in RPI, both close in wins but neither one is really looking at an at-large. The winner likely gets the edge when NCAA determines who is the last 14 and who is the first 15.

Valparaiso 15-8 (8-3, 2nd in HL) @ Ohio 17-4 (5-2, T2 in MAC)

If the MAC and the Horizon League would schedule a weekend a la the ACC/Big Ten it would make BracketBuster projections even tougher. It’s impossible to please everyone, Ohio could easily complain about drawing the biggest RPI differential of the TV match-ups. But these teams both have similar Strength of Schedule and this is a good regional match

Drake 13-9 (6-5, T3rd in MVC) @ South Dakota St. 17-6 (9-2, 2nd in Summit)

Drake pulled of a huge Triple OT win Friday night against Wichita St to secure a spot on TV and pull within 4 games of MVC leaders Creighton. Despite being 13-9, a down year for the away teams probably had them in anyway. This match-up helps South Dakota St, a win against a MVC team might give them the confidence to get past Oral Roberts in the Summit Conference tourney, but not enough for an at-large. The MVC is going to get 2 teams in, but Drake isn’t one of them right now. As the committee says “what have you done for me lately,” they need this game as well and need to get the 3 seed in the MVC tourney.

UNC Asheville 16-7 (11-1, 1st in Big South) @ George Mason 18-5 (10-1, 1st in Colonial Athletic Conference)

Newsflash the CAA is not as good as it was last year. But they still have 4 teams making it on TV, that’s because they have 3 teams with 17+ wins. George Mason’s 18 wins are not impressive whatsoever and as they are currently the leader in the conference they are likely looking at a 14 or 15 seed. This out of a conference that put a team in the Final Four last season. The leader in the Big South, UNC-Asheville isn’t exactly the win that will sway the committee but it would be GMU’s 3^rd best win on the year (they still play VCU twice though).

Drexel 17-5 (9-2, T2 in CAA) @ Davidson 15-5 (9-1, 1st in Southern)

I really wanted to send UNC Asheville to Davidson, but that would have left Drexel going to GMU, VCU, New Mexico St or Loyola MD. Had I sent them to MD. I would have been stuck with Old Dominion going to New Mex St. That doesn’t work from a regional standpoint. So this is what you get.

Texas-Arlington 15-5 (7-0, in Southland) @ New Mexico St 15-7 (5-2, 2nd in WAC)

I told you the away teams are not very good. Texas-Arlington is undefeated in conference play and by virtue of not making them travel to the East Coast they play the Aggies.

Buffalo 12-6 (5-2, T2 in MAC) @ Virginia Commonwealth 18-5 (9-2, T2nd in CAA)

I actually kicked Kent State out of a home game and moved Buffalo in. The MAC doesn’t deserve 4 teams, not when the Horizon only gets 2. Buffalo’s numbers are just as good as the Golden Flashes if not better (Since their win against WVU, what has Kent State really done)? Plus there aren’t enough good away teams. VCU trails George Mason by 1 game in the CAA (part of a three way tie). The tourney run from last year grabs one of the final home spots (considering Butler is really bad this season).

Old Dominion 14-9 (9-2, T2nd in CAA) @ Loyola Maryland 16-5 (9-2, 1st in MAAC)

Loyola MD replaced Kent State as the last home team. And minutes later replaced Iona at the top of the MAAC Standings (literally happened as I typed) and I will probably be wrong on this. The Greyhounds sports a better record, a better RPI and essentially the same strength of schedule. Kent St might draw more people and interest, but we are looking for the best match-ups. The teams most likely to be in the tournament. Right now Kent State is 4^th in their DIVISION not league DIVISION. Loyola Md is in a three-way tie for 1st in the MAAC

Standings are as of 4:15pm on Sunday - there are still some game to be played today. But none that will effect these projections.